18 Comments
Apr 2Liked by Sue Donym

Damn, yes! You deserve every "I told you so" you got in that brain of yours, and then more.

Maybe this has fast-tracked us toward the day where everyone publicly opposing a eugenics project isn't labeled Super-Hitler and put in the burn pile. Let's hope.

Expand full comment
Apr 2Liked by Sue Donym

A pleasure to see your "name" in my inbox. You were right. And I have been right for a long time thanks to your old Medium articles. I have a list of people I want to give an "I told you so" to, but I'm waiting for them to come to me. I might die first.

I'm left with the feeling that many on the "left" are in a cult. How does a lesbian not see this? Even as I tell her over and over again.

I feel sad. Let's hope this doesn't drag on forever. The waiting sucks.

Expand full comment

"My eyes rolled so hard they circumnavigated the earth long ago. I can no longer find them. This topic has worn me out.".

🙂 I can more than sympathize -- "medical scandal" and "junk science" indeed. "gender" and, in particular", "gender identity" is, as a system of personality types, hardly better than phrenology and astrology, than chinese fortune cookies.

Maybe the worst part of it is the rot and corruption that transgenderism has wrought, so to speak, in so many of our legal, educational, and scientific institutions. Apropos of which and ICYMI, see the erstwhile reputable science journal, Cell, which asks -- apparently in all seriousness -- "Is ‘sex’ a useful category?”:

https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(24)00122-3#%20

My open letter to them and its rather demented author:

https://humanuseofhumanbeings.substack.com/p/is-sex-a-useful-category

Expand full comment

So many of us have been so right for so long (I was late to the being right party by only publicly arriving in 2018). But this one comes with little pleasure, only tears of relief sometimes when some horrid child mangling policy gets rolled back here or there.

Expand full comment

And it’s very bitter and not so sweet.

I am glad that this is finally getting the coverage and attention.

But I will be upset for a long time that homophobia and misogyny can wrap around childhood medicine so easily that we can end up with the current mess.

Expand full comment

Congratulations on your bitter vindication. I've read your work over the long term and you are one of the major contributors to my G-criticality. The great feature of this era is that everyone's actions are on the record, their gleeful and triumphalist crowing on twitter etc has been recorded for the ages. Their guilt will be known to all.

Expand full comment

I can’t wait to tell people this soon.

Expand full comment

It’s annoying isn’t it. I felt I was crazy for a while when I was told what was happening wasn’t happening. Now it turns out to rationalise their previously incorrect beliefs those who told me it wasn’t happening now don’t care as it’s apparently such a negligible percentage of the population. The same negligible percentage that they once told me needed this care and help and that at the very least I should “use their pronouns”. That’s the problem with being right in such horrid situations - those who are wrong will never ever admit they supported child abuse and homophobia. How could you when you see yourself as such a virtuous individual?

Expand full comment

Yes yes yes. It’s also got by because of name calling (bigot, transphobe, etc)

Expand full comment